Were sports fans forced to accept mediocrity in 2006?
After the World Series there was a lot written about whether the Cardinals were the worst World Series champ ever. (Example A and B) What I haven’t seen written is historically how did last year’s other champions the Steelers and Heat rank. This got me thinking were the Stealers, Heat, and Cardinals collectively the worst combination of championship teams ever? My suspicions were that based on the aggregate winning percentage of the three teams last year would rank as either the worst year of champions of nearly the worst.
To test out my hypothesis I looked at the NFL, NBA, and MLB league results since 1990 and here is what I found. Obviously the Cardinals had the worst record of any Word Series winning baseball team over the period. They finished the season at 83-78, since 1990 the second worst team record wise to win the World Series was the 2000 New York Yankees 87-74. In the NFL the 11-5 Steelers and the 2002 New England Patriots were the only teams with 5 losses to win the Super Bowl since 1990. And in the NBA last year’s Miami Heat were only surpassed in losses by the 1995 Houston Rockets.
A look at overall records bears out that 2006 was collectively the worst year for champions since 1990. Furthermore by examining the composite winning percentages it becomes clear that not only was last year the worst but it was significantly worse than any other year over the period.
(more…)