If you’re anything like us, you were bemused by the media hoopla surrounding Kentucky’s embarrassing loss to Gardner-Webb.
One national writer wrote it was the college basketball equivalent of Michigan/Appalachian State. The Louisville Courier-Journal seemed to agree.
We found this bizarre. An upset like Michigan/App State had simply never happened in college football. Something like Kentucky/Gardner-Webb happens every November. (Note we’re not arguing the loss wasn’t embarrassing for a program of Kentucky’s stature, we just think people went overboard with this. Maybe this is just because it was a really slow news night.) Just last November, you’ll recall, No. 3 Kansas lost at home to Oral Roberts. In 2004 eventual national champion North Carolina lost to Santa Clara. Then there’s the granddaddy of them all — the literal equivalent of Michigan/App State — No. 1 Virginia’s loss to Chaminade, then of the NAIA, in 1982.
And for further proof that something like Kentucky/Gardner-Webb happens every year, look no further than Mercer 96, Southern Cal 81. Mercer, like Gardner-Webb, plays in the much-maligned Atlantic Sun. Mercer, like Gardner-Webb, had a poor season last year. Mercer had an 8-10 conference record (Gardner-Webb was 7-11) and finished 13-17 overall (Gardner-Webb 9-21). The two schools split their games last season, each winning at home.
Southern Cal, although lacking Kentucky’s tradition, was ranked higher than Kentucky, expected to have a better season than Kentucky, and coming off a more successful season than Kentucky.
All of which begs the question: If we’re supposed to believe Kentucky/Gardner-Webb really is the basketball equivalent of Michigan/App State (and everyone not wearing Blue Goggles seems to think so), what is the football equivalent of Southern Cal/Mercer? For now we’re going with the NFL’s New England Patriots losing at home to Notre Dame, but we’ll need more time to think about it.
Onward and upward!