Moxie Tradewinds
June 27th, 2007 by TravisMark Buehrle, Adam Dunn, Jermaine Dye, Ken Griffey Jr., Andruw Jones and Mark Teixeira. That’s the list of most attractive and available players on the market this trading season, which runs from now until July 31.
Odds are most of those guys stay put for a number of reasons. Specifically Griffey, who can veto any trade would have a very short list of teams he’d consider a trade to (which probably includes Atlanta, Seattle and the Chicago Cubs), will be impossible to move and to get fair value in return because of his contract. He’s due $20 million the following two years.
And Dunn won’t land the Cincinnati Reds much in return, either. If traded, he can become a free agent this offseason, so a team isn’t going to be willing to give up a top prospect for a three-month rental. And even if he were signed to an extension or his option next year was picked up, teams value prospects — especially young, cheap pitchers — too much to trade one for a guy who strikes out 180 times a year. His trade value will be much better this offseason if the Reds pick up his option.
Jones probably will stay in Atlanta because the Braves are going to contend the rest of the way and his season-long slump limits his value.
Buehrle and Dye are different stories. They have an aggressive GM, the Chicago White Sox’s Kenny Williams, who won’t lose them to free agency for nothing. And as soon as Teixeira gets healthy and has one good week the Rangers are going to dump him for whatever they can get.
So, what trades should we anticipate?
The MFY are going to make a hard push for Teixeira, but the best guess is they aren’t willing to give up a major prospect to land him. And a team like the Angels of Anaheim can probably afford to because of their deep farm system and will pull the trigger. If that happens, it might actually work out swimmingly for the Reds. No, they still probably can’t move Dunn for fair value, but it might mean they can unload Scott Hatteberg on the MFY for something/anything/nothing in order to make room for Triple-A stud Joey Votto.
Dye carries a major inury flag, but the Mets, Cubs, Braves and Twins could all use his right-handed bat. My bet would be on the Mets or Cubs with the Cubs most aggressive. They’d like to unload Jacque Jones, but he would net practically nothing. Williams will demand a prospect for Dye.
And Williams will demand two — if not three - prospects for Buehrle. Yes, Buehrle is just a rental, but pitchers actually maintain their value at midseason while hitters don’t net as much return as in the offseason. Teams desparate for an arm can be held hostage by a team squandering away its season like the White Sox.
Plus, there will be many suitors. The Red Sox, MFY, Mets, Braves and Marlins have already been rumored to show interest. The team that needs Buehrle the most is Philadelphia with John Leiber out for the season and Bret Myers and Tom Gordon still on the shelf.
It’d be shocking if the Red Sox traded for him, although injuries to Curt Schilling and Julian Tavarez have taken a hit on starting pitching depth. But Jon Lester and Clay Bucholtz are competent stopgaps until those two return rather than trading one of their futures for three months of up-and-down Buehrle.
Of course the MFY will make a run, but Buehrle isn’t much better than what they already have. If they get him it will mearly be to give the appearance of improving to The Boss. Beurhle won’t make the MFY MF-better.
So, Buehrle seems destined for the NL East. The Mets seem the most likely destination given their need and their aggressiveness. But the Braves never go quietly, and the Phillies may finally feel the fan pressure to make a move. They’ve always started slow and come on after the break when it was too late. This year, they started slow but flipped the switch early enough to be in the race at the All-Star Break.



